dimabagow

St. Matthew Island

A very instructive story. In 1944, 29 reindeer were introduced to St. Matthew Island. With abundant forage and no resident reindeer predators, the population reached about 6,000 in 1963. This corresponds to an average compound increase of roughly 32% per year over 19 years; it does not mean the rate was identical every year.

The crash occurred mainly during the winter of 1963-1964, rather than gradually over the next three years. The 1966 survey found 42 survivors: 41 females and one male. David R. Klein's 1968 study connected the die-off with depleted forage, competition and exceptionally severe winter conditions, including deep snow. It is incorrect to dismiss the weather as too mild to matter.

Carrying capacity means the population that a habitat can support under specified conditions; it varies with vegetation, seasons and weather. It is not a fixed density that can be read directly from one population count. Using an island area of approximately 332 km², 1,350 animals in 1957 means about 4.1 per km², not 5. The peak of 6,000 corresponds to about 18 per km², and 42 survivors to about 0.126 per km².

The population could continue growing while its winter food reserve was being depleted. Lichens recover slowly, so habitat damage can persist for decades. But “slow recovery” does not establish irreversible loss, and the small surviving herd does not by itself prove that recovery was impossible.

The drop from 6,000 to 42 is approximately 99.3% of the population. Neither that figure nor the previously quoted 97.5% is a measured percentage loss of the island's carrying capacity. Population decline and a change in habitat capacity are different quantities.

I think many people should read this history: abundant resources and rapid growth do not remove ecological limits, and a depleted food reserve can make a severe winter catastrophic.